buy property to prevent


Neighbors Buying Property To Prevent The Establishment Of A Group Home The Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law Issue: Housing About News In court Take action Publications More resources Topics : Information sheets Advocacy resources on fair housing Jump to an issue: Advance Psych. Directives Children Civil Rights and the ADA Criminalization Education Elders with Mental Illnesses Housing Insurance Involuntary Commitment Managed Care Medicaid Medicare Rx Drug Benefit Mental Healthcare Privacy Restraint and Seclusion Supports in the Community - SSI - Temp. Assist. for Families Voting Fair Housing Information Sheet # 3 Neighbors Buying Property To Prevent The Establishment Of A Group Home Imagine the following scenario: A house in a residential neighborhood is for sale. A provider of residential services to persons with mental retardation believes that the house would be a great location for a group home for three women and submits a bid to purchase the house. Neighbors of the seller learn of the provider's interest in the home and meet to develop strategies for preventing the women from moving into the neighborhood. Eventually, the neighbors conclude that the only way to prevent the provider from purchasing the home is to submit a higher bid. The neighbors realize that none of them can afford to buy the home alone, so they pool their resources, give the money collected to one of the neighbors, and that person offers the seller $5,000 more for the home than does the provider. The seller sells the home to the neighbor acting on behalf of the group. Do the actions of the seller or of the neighbors who purchased the home violate the Fair Housing Act? The FHA makes it unlawful to discriminate in the sale or rental, or to otherwise make unavailable or deny, a dwelling to any buyer or renter because of a handicapof (A) that buyer or renter; (B) a person residing in or intending to reside in that dwelling after it is so sold, rented, or made available; or (C) any person associated with that buyer or renter. 42 U.S.C. 3604(f)(1). The FHA contains an exemption for single-family houses sold or rented by an owner, provided that the owner does not use the services of a real estate agent or broker, own more than three such single-family houses, and, if the owner is not a resident, has not completed more than one sale within a 24-month period. 42 U.S.C. 3603(b). Thus, assuming the listed conditions are met, it is likely that the owner cannot be found liable under the 3604(f)(1) of the FHA. But what of the neighbors, who banded together to buy the home in order to prevent persons with disabilities from living there? Courts that have faced this and similar scenarios have answered the question in different ways. In Michigan Protection and Advocacy Service, Inc. v. Babin , 18 F.3d 337, 344 (6 th Cir. 1994), the Sixth Circuit called action similar to that described above as "normal economic competition." The Babin court analyzed the liability of the neighbors who contributed extra funds to make the purchase possible under 3604(f)(1), specifically the "otherwise make unavailable" provision. The court explained that, in normal economic competition, every purchase of a unique commodity affects availability to others. Thus, the court concluded, finding the neighbors liable would cause the statute's reach to be overbroad, and it affirmed the summary judgment entered by the court below. A claim also was asserted against the seller and the neighbors pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 3617, which makes illegal interfering with the exercise and enjoyment of the right to fair housing. The Sixth Circuit also rejected this argument, finding that the seller was motivated purely by economic considerations and that, while the purchase of the house disrupted the provider's negotiations, it did not prevent the provider from making an even higher bid on the property. Babin, then, stands for the proposition that actions related to the purchase of property — even when taken for the sole reason of preventing the use of that property by persons protected under the FHA — is "normal economic competition" and therefore is not a violation of the FHA. Not every court that has considered the issue since the Babin decision has agreed with that proposition, however. In United States v. Hughes , 849 F. Supp. 685 (D. Neb. 1994), the court denied a motion to dismiss and found the Babin decision "plainly wrong" in suggesting that there is an economic competition exception to the FHA. In Hughes , the court determined that a lender, who agreed to finance the purchase of property knowing that the intention of the buyer was to prevent the establishment of a group home, could be liable under 42 U.S.C. 3617. The court held that a bank violates the FHA by intentionally aiding buyers in keeping a home from other purchasers because those other purchasers are or are associated with persons with mental illness: [T]rue ' economic competition' does not exist when the purpose of the competition is to deny a protected person access to housing, as opposed to securing housing for oneself or for investment purposes. In fact, it is irrational to spend money for the purpose of prohibiting someone else from living next to you, if the reason you do not wish to live next to that person is because he or she has a handicap protected by the Act.-- Hughes at 686 (emphasis in original). A third opinion on this issue adopts the Hughes analysis. In Step-by-Step v. Lazarus , No. CV-97-1006 (M.D. Pa. Oct. 17, 1997), the court, in denying a motion to dismiss, held that the FHA "does apply to a buyer who purchases a property with the intention of preventing the purchase by an entity planning to use the property as a Group Home for members protected by the Act." Id. , slip op. at 1. In reaching this conclusion, the court agreed with the Hughes reasoning and stated that normal economic considerations do not exist where the underlying intent of the purchaser is to discriminate. The court found support for this proposition in 24 C.F.R. 103.20(a), which allows the filing of a complaint against "any person" engaged in a discriminatory housing practice, and in 24 C.F.R. 100.50(b)(3), which makes it unlawful to engage in "any conduct" that denies or makes housing unavailable to persons with disabilities. As these cases demonstrate, determining the motives of a buyer, seller, or neighbors and whether such motives are legally relevant is a complex issue. On the one hand, Congress has clearly mandated an end to discrimination in housing, and a narrow interpretation of the FHA, such as in Babin , allows persons with discriminatory intent to prevent individuals with disabilities from moving into a community. On the other hand, examining the private motives to all the various parties to a real estate transaction may be both unwieldy and burdensome. Clearly, it is helpful to fair housing advocates that the reasoning in Babin — even though articulated by an appellate court — was not convincing to the next two courts to consider very similar situations. While it remains too soon to make any definitive pronouncements on the merits of the issues, it is apparent, given the holdings in Hughes and Step-by-Step , that the actions of neighbors who buy property to prevent the establishment of group homes remain subject to viable challenge under the FHA. This information sheet was produced under a contract with the Advocacy Training/Technical Assistance Center of the National Association of Protection & Advocacy Systems For more information, contact Michael Allen, Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law, 1101 15th Street, N.W., Suite 1212 Washington, D.C. 20005-5002. Phone: 202/467-5730 ext. 117. E-mail: Michaela@bazelon.org . Judge David L. Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law 1101 15th Street, NW, Suite 1212 Washington, DC 20005 Phone: 202-467-5730 Fax: 202-223-0409 Email: webmaster@bazelon.org Judge David L. Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law 1101 15th Street, NW, Suite 1212 Washington, DC 20005 Phone: 202-467-5730 Fax: 202-223-0409 Email: webmaster@bazelon.org



Home Loan

Military.com -- Benefiting the US Army, US Navy, US Air Force, Marine Corps, Coast Guard Welcome! My Account | Login | Logout My Account Email Address Book Newsletters Unit Pages Military Spouses Education School Finder College Credit Scholarships GI Bill Money Military Pay VA Loans Insurance Deals Relocation Car Buying Military Discounts Careers Job Search Post a Job Promotion Alerts Military Careers Networking Job Hunting Tips For Severely Injured Join the Military Ace the ASVAB Insider's Secrets Reserve & Guard Find Recruiters News Military Headlines Military Report Early Brief Military Opinion Newsletters Shopping Gear Medals & Ribbons Discount Center Grocery Coupons Community Units & Tributes Buddy Finder Military Reunions Military History Entertainment Travel Trivia Challenge Movies Books Humor Games Shock & Awe Equipment Military Network Military Benefits Military Locator SearchMilitary GI Bill Express Fredsplace The Few Vets2Vote Legislative Action SoldierTech Defense Tech Buddy Finder | Newsletters | Discussions | Jobs | Scholarships | Trivia | Discounts | Networking England Leaves Top Navy Post Navy Secretary Gordon England - who has also been serving as the acting deputy defense secretary - relinquished his Navy post Thursday, clearing the way for Donald Winter. Full Story Today's Headlines Iraq Election Results to be Reviewed Congress Revives Missile Killed by DOD Wars Lack Medal of Honor Two Marines Cleared in Rape Case Corps Pays $100K for Retooled Jeep Today's Features Military.com takes a look back on 2005. Join us as we examine 20 of the most significant events that affected the military community. Launch Slideshow Video: Atomic Bomb Watch old footage of a cannon shooting off an atomic bomb. Visit Shock & Awe Sub's Unmanned Buddy Rapid Fire 12/28/05 Free Press in Kurdistan, Take Two Resources Choose a Resource ----------------------------------- Pay and Related Benefits Reserve Drill Pay Guard Drill Pay Installation Guides TRICARE & Medical Benefits Education Help Equipment Guides Mentor Network Veteran Jobs Unit Homepages Military Discounts GI Bill VA Loans Scholarships Buddy Finder Space A Travel Relocation Veterans Benefits Retiree Help Pages Military Forms Museum Guide Awards & Decorations Records & Appeals Entertainment Adventure in the Boondocks Games: Ghost Recon 2 DVDs: Silent Night Books: Military Advantage Daily Trivia | Games | Humor | More Military Lifestyle FITNESS: How to Train for Ruck Marches Stew Smith shares some training notes on how to prepare for the Ruck Marches. Deployment & the Marriage Decision ECKHART: Invisible Unless They Cry GOMULKA: Food Stamps are Not the Answer SMILEY: Children's Birthday Party Military.com | Newsletters | About Us | Work at Military.com | Advertising | Affiliate Program | Monster Network Help & Feedback | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | ©2005 Military Advantage



property listings throughout the

Commercial Real Estate Listings Commercial Real EstateListings Vandema Vandema Commercial Real Estate Home Surplus Government R. E. | Surplus Corporate R. E. Realtor Listings | Foreclosure Listings Commercial Properties for Sale or Lease by Barry, Inc. - Includes listed land, office, industrial and retail properties. MrOfficeSpace.com - Office space for lease in a number of U.S. metros. RealEstateExchange.com - Multiple listing service for the exchange or sale of commercial and investment property. Bed & Breakfast for Sale - Listing directory of small lodging properties, hotels and inns for sale. Retreat Properties - Retreats, ranches or resort properties available for redevelopment in North and Central America. Private Islands Online - Directory of private islands for sale. Hotel Realty Resource - Listings of hotels, motels, inns and restaurants. Hotels & Motels FSBO - For sale by owner hotels, motels, b&b's and other lodging establishments. NAIDirect.com - Available office, retail, industrial, development properties and apartments buildings. Web-Real-Estate.com - Search for commercial and investment real estate for sale or lease. Storetrax.com - Directory of available retail space. RV Parks & Campgrounds For Sale ResortsForSale.Com - On-line guide to resorts for sale in North America, featuring photos, descriptions and contact info. CommercialSearch.com - Listing services for office, industrial, retail, residential, hotel, land and farm property. Loopnet Listing Services - Database of real estate for sale or lease throughout North America. FIABCI - Members Properties for Sale FIABCI - Members Properties for Lease Hotel / Motel For Sale Listings - Directory by state. COMMREX Listings - Search investment, commercial and industrial property listings throughout the U.S. Listings of Farms and Farmland - Land and farms for sale. Get in touch with us by Other Commercial Real Estate Resources



Buy Home Networking Products

PCWorld.com - How to Buy Home Networking Products ')-- Cameras PCs Laptops Printers Monitors Spyware DVD VoIP IN THIS GUIDE Introduction The Big Picture The Specs Explained Home Networking Shopping Tips RELATED ARTICLES Network Storage for Home and Business First WiMax Products Will Soon Get Nod HP Warns About Flaw in Network Management Product Internet Tips: Access Your Files and Apps From Anywhere for Free Sun's Grid Stumbles See all related items Topics > Internet & Networking > Networking > How to Buy Home Networking Products « Previous 1 2 3 4 Next » Introduction If your home or small office has two or more PCs, you'll be pleasantly surprised by how many problems a network solves. Tired of sharing files by ferrying floppies? Exhausted by battling a spouse or coworker over who gets the new printer or access to a broadband Internet account? These issues go away once your PCs are connected and talking to each other. The Big Picture Learn the benefits and drawbacks of the different types of wired and wireless networks. more The Specs Explained Find out how to make sure a network is fast and secure enough for your needs. more Home Networking Shopping Tips Read our strategies for picking out the best networking technology before you start shopping. more Next page: The Big Picture « Previous 1 2 3 4 Next » Photograph by: Rick Rizner PC World Magazine Get 2 Risk-Free Issues and 15 Free Gifts! Customer Service and Subscriptions Sponsored Info Leading Peripheral Mfg. Announces New Brand - BenQ -- Microsoft's Visual Studio.Net packs powerful productivity wallop -- PCWorld.com Picks and Promotions -- NEW! Super Guide to Photo Editing NEW! Super Guide to PC Protection Free PC World Newsletters Security for Small Business Eliminate PC Annoyances -- Shop Now Online RSS Feeds About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Corrections | Member Services | Site Map Terms of Service Agreement | ASME Guidelines | Privacy Statement | IDG International IDG NETWORK: CIO Computerworld CSO GamePro GamerHelp Infoworld ITWorld Canada JavaWorld Macworld MikroDatorn Network World PC Advisor PC-Welt PC World Latin America Playlist tecCHANNEL Techworld



Colorado Real Estate

Breckenridge Lodging-colorado Real Estate Skiing Snowboarding information Summit County colorado. Today Snow High: 28 to 32 Tonight Snow Low: 10 to 15 -- If you would like to be kept informed on things going on in Breckenridge such as weather , lodging specials , cool stuff and more, then sign up for our email club now. BreckNet is the Breckenridge Colorado local information source for Breckenridge, Colorado and all of Summit County, Colorado. Step inside to learn more about this gorgeous alpine town and its surrounding areas, located high in the Central Rockies of Summit County, Colorado. BreckNet lists lodging companies and lodging specials as well as Real Estate companies in case you're looking to buy. Locals say the best things about Breckenridge Colorado are the endless opportunities for R&R. Talk about recreation ! Come in the summer to hear a concert, play golf, hike, camp, bike, fish, kayak, ride horses, or just go shopping ! There's something to do every minute of the day. Ski Breckenridge Lodging Call Toll Free: 1-800-754-9378 In the winter , enjoy some of the best skiing in the world. Our snow is light, soft, and plentiful! Check the list of Breckenridge Colorado ski and snowboard shops to save time with rentals. Winter in Breckenridge Colorado offers excitement and romance with skiing, snowboarding, ice skating, snowmobiling, sleigh rides, helicopter skiing, apres-ski entertainment , and candlelight dining . Looking for a deal? SkiCoupons.Com is the answer. Find tons of printable coupons for steals & deals on a wide range of products and services in the area like; lodging, dining, tours, shopping, skiing, rafting, golf, fishing, sportsgear, and much, much more! Check out their website today! Click here for air fare. Click here for Car Rentals. P.O. Box 1318 - 101 North Main Street, Suite 6 Breckenridge, Colorado 80424 For advertising information, Call 970-547-9690 - email chip@colorado.net - or visit www.inw.biz Email, dial-up or DSL Questions? Contact our sister company, VailNet/ColoradoNet 949-3318 * http://isp.vail.net




 Home

 Real Estate

 Real Estate Agents

 Real Estate Investment

 Real Estate Loans

 Real Estate Listings

 Florida Real Estate

 Real Estate Corporation

 Las Vegas Real Estate

 Real Estate and Rental

 Colorado Real Estate

 Real Estate Investing

 Homes For Sale

 Home Mortgage

 Selling Home

 Real Estate License Forms

 Rental Property

 Investment Property

 Real Estate

 Purchase Property

 Foreclosure Property

 Real Estate Board: Abitibi

 Real Estate

 Real Estate Learning Center

 Real Estate -Commercial -Construction

 Real Estate Real Estate

 REAL ESTATE FORECLOSURES Valuecom

 real estate professionals,and the

 Real Estate Vail Real

 Real Estate

 Real Estate Banner Network

 Real Estate - Homes

 Real Estate Agents This

 REAL ESTATE CLIPART where

 Real Estate Fund Managers

 Real Estate Management, 15th

 Real Estate Sales Summit

 Real Estate Licensing Bill

 Real Estate Course Search

 Real Estate MIT established

 Real Estate Real Estate

 Real Estate | Rentals

 Real estate successis a

 Real Estate Advertise Save

 Real Estate Inspector --

 Real Estate Agents This

 Real Estate Agent

 Real estate agents usually

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent! --

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent By

 Real estate agents help

 real estate agent Tommy

 Real estate agents usually

 Real Estate Agent

 real estate agents Money

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent that

 Real Estate Agents &

 Real Estate Agent Webpages

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agents The

 Real Estate Agents Career

 real estate agents. While

 Real Estate Agents FAQs

 Real Estate Agents |

 Real Estate Agent License

 Real Estate Agent Find

 real estate agents because

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent Listings

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agent: It's

 real estate agents to

 Real Estate Agent Moorestown

 real estate agents to

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agents Apartments

 real estate agent here.

 Real Estate agent Property

 Real Estate Agent

 Real Estate Agents You

 real estate investment trust

 Real Estate Investment Software

 Real Estate Investment Courses

 real estate investment course

 Real Estate Investment Opportunities

 real estate investment information

 Real Estate Investments AreSafe,

 Real Estate Investment

 real estate investment as

 Real Estate Investment, Seller

 real estate investment seminars