real estate prices in

MemeFirst: New York real-estate prices explained -- MemeFirst December 01, 2005 New York real-estate prices explained The 2.2 million jobs in Manhattan pay, on average, $2,025 per week . (You know that feeling you get when you find out you're below average? I've been having that for years.) Manhattan is 22 square miles, which means that the island of Manhattan pays, on average, $378 per square foot per year . And that includes Washington Heights. Posted by Felix at 02:54 PM GMT All proceeds go to MSF -- Comments #1 Pity we can't all work for Goldman Sachs. Posted by: Gherimiah on December 1, 2005 03:28 PM #2 I'll happily defer to someone with a firmer grasp of stats on this, but in the meantime, I wonder, does that average income number tell you very much? Given the massive disparity in Manhattan incomes, between, say, the dishwasher and the hedge-fund owner, which surely are among the widest in the country, wouldn't you also need to know the distribution of the data points? At a minium, wouldn't you want also to know the median income? Also, is this net or gross? Article talked about paychecks, which could probably mean either. Posted by: Matthew on December 1, 2005 04:36 PM #3 Oh, and also, Felix, presumably the 2.2 million people with jobs in Manhattan don't all live there, so your extrapolation doesn't wash. Posted by: Matthew on December 1, 2005 04:38 PM #4 Obvs mean incomemedian income, and I'd be surprised if more than 40% of Manhattanites made above average. Probably less. But even so. And actually, the fact that there are 2.2 million jobs to 1.5 million people in Manhattan actually only serves to exacerbate the demand-supply imbalance when it comes to real estate. Posted by: Felix on December 1, 2005 04:53 PM #5 I hate to be the one to break this to you, Felix, but nearly all residential housing in Manhattan consists of multi-story buildings. The salary range you describe explains real estate prices in Westchester County, NY and Bergen County, NJ to about the same degree as prices in Manhattan. Posted by: Sterling on December 1, 2005 07:05 PM #6 How delightful that the discussion of property prices one is sometimes unable to defuse at dinner parties just carries on here - almost as if taunting one with its dreary ineluctability. And how nice that Felix should bring along his no doubt expert appreciation of statistical lore. The one thing I am missing is the crucial evaluation of bedbug incidence as it affects property prices in Manhattan. In another thread, Betty has said this bedbug malarkey is all a plan of Bush's. For myself, I prefer to recall that bedbugs tend to originate in Belgium. Schtumm for now. More on this later. Posted by: Claude de Bigny on December 1, 2005 08:40 PM #7 Also, this seems to imply that everyone pays all of their income for housing, which is hopefully not the case. To be more realistic (ignoring the issues rightly brought up by the other commentators, including whether all of those people actually live in Manhattan and whether you can just take the sq ftge of Manhattan as the residential sq ftge), say people on average spend 40% of their income on housing. That gets your income for housing per sq ft to around $151. Posted by: Susan on December 1, 2005 09:14 PM #8 Susan and Sterling, you are embarassingly confused. What percentage of real estate in Manhattan is used for housing? According to this http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/pdf/landusefacts/landuse_tables.pdf (in case you are confused by the graph, the percents sum together veritcally and the land area sum horizontally). And even assuming that all "Mixed Residential and Commercial" was used for housing, less than 38% of the land in Manhattan is for housing. These data certainly allow for the idea that much of rent paid in Manhattan is for commercial use, and even then, a considerable percent is used for public space (Central Park alone is 10% of the area of Manhattan). Anyway, the amount people earn in a particular location is not directly related to the amount the people who live there earn, or the amount the people live there pay for rent. Look at this site: http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/saipe/index.html The direct link is unavailable, but the Median household income for New York County was 43,573. Nassau County on the other hand is more than 71,000. In which place is it cheaper to rent by the foot? Posted by: Andrew on December 2, 2005 07:22 AM #9 I don't think I'm confused. My points are: a) there is actually quite a bit more than 22 square miles of residential floor space in Manhattan because of vertical construction b) a lot of upper-income Manhattan workers live outside Manhattan, and their buying power lifts prices in tony bedroom communities Posted by: Sterling on December 3, 2005 03:38 PM #10 OK, Sterling, let's do it your way. Assume that each of the 1.5 million residents of Manhattan has 400 square feet to call their own: that works out to 1200 square feet for the average family of three and 1600 square feet for the average family of four. Generous, I'd say. That comes out to 600 million square feet of residential real estate in Manhattan. Using that figure, my calculation actually comes out slightly higher : $386 per square foot per year, rather than $378. What makes you think that there's more than 22 square miles of residential floor space in Manhattan? As for your point b, I fail to see how it is in any way germane. Posted by: Felix on December 3, 2005 11:09 PM #11 OK, 22 square miles equals about 613,324,800 square feet. That would leave each of Manhattan's 1.5 million residents with 409 square feet of living space. But I don't believe that most Manhattan residents are actually so deprived, especially when you take into account common areas in apartment buildings such as laundry facilities, hallways, lobbies, etc. I'd be surprised if the average wasn't at least 600, and it's probably more than 800. And besides, that's not what you originally meant - you were dividing Manhattan's land footprint and not taking into account its vertical expansion. As for the second point, I suspect there's a strong tendency among $100,000 - $1,000,000 per annum Manhattan earners - which is well-off to wealthy-on-a-budget - to live in places like Valhalla and Ho-Ho-Kus, especially if they're married with kids. Family-flight in turn increases the average per-capita-square-footage of the Manhattan residential footprint through bleed-off of children. Posted by: Sterling on December 4, 2005 02:29 AM #12 Sterling jumped the shark so long ago it's probably not surprising, but for those of you keeping score at home, he really did just say that the average Manhattanite has 800 square feet of their own. So if you're an average person living with 2 roommates, that means you're in a 2400 square foot apartment. In Manhattan. Yeah. Oh, and that 350 square foot apartment you've got? It's not 350 square feet at all, it's probably more than 4000 square feet. You're just not including the lobby and all the hallways. Posted by: Felix on December 4, 2005 02:43 AM #13 My claim is that the amount of residential-zoned floor space in Manhattan probably works out to between 600 and 800 square feet per resident of Manhattan. You're not only challenging this, but asserting that my claim is absurd. Sure you wanna do that? Posted by: Sterling on December 4, 2005 02:59 AM #14 I've tried to find the statistic, but to no avail. It seems that while office space inventor is measured in square footage, residential space is simply measured, in all documents, by units. But we can work with that. So far I've learned that 82% of zoned lots in Manhattan are residential, making up about 280,000,000 square feet, which includes permanently undeveloped spaces like yards and gardens. If the average height of development across all that land is four stories, then, we're looking at about 750 square feet per person. I've also learned that in 1999 there were about 727,000 residential units in Manhattan , which means that the average unit houses two people. So those three-roomies crammed into one 800-square-foot-tenement-with-the-bathtub-in-the-kitchen examples are mostly fiction. Which is a shame because I get a tingle from the mental picture of Manhattan twenty- and thirty-somethings living in cramped, dingy conditions. If we divide the total residential land area by the total number of units, we get 385 square feet, which works out to 192.5 square feet per person, assuming no dwellings above one story in height and no unimproved/vacant land. If the average height is assumed to be four stories, in this scenario we get about 770 square feet per person. Here's a report from Prudential Douglas Elliman that details its 1Q 2005 sales. Units sold averaged 1,334 square feet, which divided by two yields 767 square feet per person. Breaking it down further we find co-ops averaging 1,197 square feet, condos at 1,496 square feet, luxury at 2,921 and loft at 2,145. So that's 598.5 square feet per person at the low end all the way up to 1,460.5 at the top. There's three separate analytical models for you Felix, all of which yield per-person square footage of 750 or better. I admit they're not all that fleshed out, but I'm stuck inside with a cold watching The Taking of Pelham One-Two-Three on DVD, and I'm disinclined to dig deeper. But you're welcome to. Posted by: Sterling on December 4, 2005 04:04 AM #15 Sterling: do your calculations include infrastructure or is the 280MM number a percentage of raw space? Building density is higher here than anywhere else in America, but 15% to circulation (in buildings and streets themeselves) would be an easily defended metric. Counting hallways in urban residential structures is like counting sidewalks as part of sf for suburban homes. As much Sterling does sound like a set designer for Friends, Felix, I gotta say, of the 25 or so apartments of people that I can definitely make an estimate of size, we average 500 sf easy. Most everyone is a half a standard tenement lot (25 x 25), with a couple of lofts and post-war, large-scale developments thrown in. This is skewed because many of them are single (I live in a 2bd alone) or have rent-controlled apartments from way back. Posted by: 99 on December 4, 2005 07:19 PM #16 Where does your 280m sq ft number come from? Your first two calculations are based on it, so I'd like to know. (They're also based on a multiplier of 4, which as far as I can tell came pretty much out of thin air.) As for apartment sales, in Manhattan individual condos and coops tend to be much larger than the apartments inside rental buildings. So if you look just at sold apartments as opposed to rented apartments, you're going to get a skewed figure. What's more, if a 3800-square-foot brownstone in Harlem, say, is sold and then the downstairs floor is rented out, that still counts as a 3800 square foot deal under these figures. Posted by: Felix on December 4, 2005 09:21 PM #17 The multiplier of 4 was back-of-envelope guess. The 280,000,000 number came from this PDF . Sorry, thought I'd linked to it initially. As for rental apartments being smaller than privately owned condos or co-ops...not sure I buy that. But even if it's true, how much smaller could they be? 10%? Doesn't really matter. You can apologize any time now. Posted by: Sterling on December 4, 2005 10:06 PM #18 if anyone is real curious why not pony up the $250 to get a list of every tax lot in the city? http://www.nyc.gov/html/dcp/html/bytes/applbyte.shtml in the meantime, simply because i am tired of having to read sterlings pontifications about things he knows anything about, i downloaded a list of all the residential tax lots from 14th street and below from propertyshark. only 14th street and below, because after 6000+ entries, i became bored. 14th street down is a good representative sample of the 99000+ residential tax lots in manhattan. it includes spacious luxury lofts of tribeca, tenements of the les, projects on the eastside, high rise high density battery park and half building condo conversions of downtown (note that a rental bldg with multiple units counts as a single tax lot with the number of units listed as a seperate data field). the average unit size works out to 1100sf with 590sf per person (based 2000 census population stats for 14th st & below). this includes all common space in a building as it is based on total building size for single tax lot (rental) buildings and counts common space tax lots for condo buildings (read lobbies, circ, etc.) multiplying back out by the 2000 census population numbers for manhattan of 1,537,195... we get 906,945,050sf of residential space in manhattan. let's call that an even 9Bsf since the city lists 3800 acres of lot area in manhattan (165,500,000sf), that gives a rough overbuild factor of 5.5. this will obviously skew higher with the ues & uws densities without actually affecting the sf/person. summary- -590sf of residential per person (inclusive of common areas). close to sterlings low estimate of 600, but nowhere near the 800sf -1100sf average size per unit (inclusive of common areas). again close to sterlings guess based on broker mumbojumbo, but still below the stated average. -9Bsf of residential space in manhattan sterling- close on your numbers, but not nearly close enough to be quite so pompously smug. stick to things you know about, like why bush is a foreign policy genius. felix- remind me what this related to? Posted by: geoff on December 5, 2005 12:34 AM #19 Geoff - The only reason I was pompously snug is because Felix had reacted to to my estimates with such comedic outrage. Also, I don't think 14th St. and below is a good representative sample. Newer and I suspect more spacious high-rises make up a much larger proportion of housing from the 30s up through the low 100s. So I'm sticking with 600+. I suspect the actual number is around 750, as stated above. As for your justification of your work - "simply because i am tired of having to read sterlings pontifications about things he knows anything about" - I'm not sure what it means. Perhaps you meant to write "nothing" instead of "anything"? I'm not claiming to be right all the time - I am not right all the time. I am, however, pretty much always right whenever Felix gets all worked up and tells me I have no idea what I'm talking about. Thanks for your small role in marking off another example for me to throw back at him at some future date. Posted by: Sterling on December 5, 2005 06:19 AM #20 Renter-occupied apartments are much smaller than owner-occupied apartments. And as the PDF you yourself linked to shows (see page 24), the vast majority of apartments in Manhattan are renter-occupied. Think about it: one needs maybe 350 sq ft per person to live in some reasonable comfort. Beyond that, you're shelling out extra cash for extra space. Owners are happy doing that because they have 100% equity in that space: everyone has heard the advice that they should buy the biggest apartment they can afford. Renters, on the other hand, are simply giving away thousands of dollars in rent every month, with nothing at all to show for it. So they tend to go not for the biggest apartment they can afford, but rather the cheapest apartment they find adequate. Put it this way: Manhattan is full of individuals spending an enormous proportion of their income on outsize mortgage payments. Almost everyone, when they move from renting to buying, sees their monthly housing costs rise substantially. If you move to Manhattan and have a relatively low income, then you might spend a crazy amount of it on rent, it's true. But if your income is average or higher (and remember that average is $2,025 per week), I very much doubt that your rent is making nearly as much of a dent in your paycheck as it would if you owned your own apartment. You reach a standard of living you're comfortable with, and you stop. Anything beyond that is money which you could otherwise spend on clothes, or travel, or restaurants. Whereas if you buy , you're not spending so much as investing. The only money which you're really spending is the interest on your mortgage -- and even that comes with a tax deduction. Or let's put it another way. That Elliman report you linked to has an average sales price of $1.21 million. A typical rental yield in Manhattan these days is 4%, so if rentals were functionally identical to owner-occupied apartments, which you seem to assume, then the average rent in Manhattan would be over $4,000 a month. In fact, of course, it's nowhere near that. Posted by: Felix on December 5, 2005 06:55 AM #21 There's the shark, and then there's the A train. Sterling's Manhattan clearly stops at 96th street. Sterling, dear, north of that bright white line, the housing stock is incredibly stable and consistent in terms of size and layout. Harlem is just now getting it's first 'luxury' apartment building in a half century. Any larger apartment complexes are housing projects, which have smaller units by definition, and, allowing for the dispersal of the towers in some International Style fantasy also insures that the density does not increase much. Posted by: 99 on December 5, 2005 04:03 PM #22 Felix, just because apartments are currently going for $1.21 million a pop doesn't mean that everyone who owns an apartment paid that much. Rent prices move in sympathy with real estate prices but are less prone to bubbles. What you're missing here, and you've missed the same thing when we've talked about the stock market in the past, is the difference between speculative investors and income investors. Speculators don't buy an apartment (or apartment building) primarily for the benefit of the rent; their main motivation is the hope of flipping the property at some later date for a larger sum than they paid for it. The current Manhattan real estate bubble is the product of speculators. Real estate income investors view rent collection as their goal - most apartment buildings in any town or city in the U.S. are owned by income investors. They get less press than speculators, but they also tend to go bankrupt less often. The market value of a rental property can be determined by the amount of rent it generates for the owner, not the other way around. Manhattan rents are high - probably even ludicrously high - but that is a function of large demand chasing relatively low supply, and is only weakly related to current real estate prices. I do acknowledge your point about space not being a priority for Manhattan renters, there is some truth in that. People who do see space as a necessity tend to wind up in rental units in Brooklyn, Queens or Hudson County. But that's not exclusively the case. Posted by: Sterling on December 5, 2005 04:59 PM #23 This thread is hilarious and sad, although a good example of how the same statistics can be applied to support any and all political positions. Posted by: sac on December 5, 2005 06:39 PM #24 Sterling, Manhattan is the one real-estate market in the US where there are, to all intents and purposes, zero speculators under your definition. No one buys Manhattan property in order to flip it. For one thing, co-op boards (and even condo boards, for that matter) hate flippers, and are likely to punish them. There's flip taxes, brokers' fees of 6% for the seller, and a luxury tax of 1% on any apartment over $1m for the buyer. Prices are so high that the carrying costs are enormous -- and you can't rent out the apartment in the meantime, because that makes it pretty much unsaleable. There are, of course, lots of buildings owned by income investors in New York. Most of the East Village, where I live, is comprised of such buildings: they normally have 20 or so apartments (say 5 floors, 4 apartments per floor), and they've been going up in price almost as much as individual apartments have -- the only reason they haven't gone up just as much is because many of the tenants are rent-controlled or rent-stabilised below market. These are typical New York apartments, from a renter's point of view -- but I can tell you, as someone who was apartment hunting in the East Village for almost a year, they're much less typical from an owner's point of view. Also, there's a strong incentive for for-sale apartments to be as large as possible: price per square foot is positively correlated with size. That's not the case in the rental market: it's easier to rent out a 650sqft apartment for $2500 than it is to rent out a 1300sqft apartment for $5000. Posted by: Felix on December 5, 2005 09:14 PM #25 "Manhattan is the one real-estate market in the US where there are, to all intents and purposes, zero speculators under your definition. No one buys Manhattan property in order to flip it." Felix, of course people speculate on property in Manhattan. Just because the barriers to entry are high doesn't mean some won't jump them. How else do you think a modest apartment winds up costing as much as a dozen Mercedes-Benz CL500s? Who do you imagine is providing demand at that level? You know banks are not issuing $1,000,000 mortgages to households with joint incomes of $200,000. It's trust fund kiddies - who are often divorced from fiscal reality - and speculators. As for your point about different-sized apartments being suitable for rent versus sale, I might agree with you except for the fact that every rental apartment IS OWNED by someone. It IS PART of the for sale market. I'd be surprised if fewer than half of the condos in Manhattan are rented out by their owners. Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 01:51 AM #26 Sterling, I'm afraid the factors leading to high apartment prices are much more mundane than your feverish mind would like to imagine. Lots of global liquidity, driving down interest rates and banks' credit tests. Lots of demand, due to Manhattan's status as the center of the universe and high Wall Street bonuses. And very limited supply. The market for flippers is Miami, not NYC -- where a condo can be bought and sold three or four times before it is even built. As for your point about rental apartments being owned by someone, it sounds clever until you stop to think about what I've already said. Rental buildings are owned by landlords; the vast majority of condos and co-ops are owner-occupied. For one thing, co-ops vastly outnumber condos, and they're hard to rent. And as for condos, they generally get rented out when they're not the place their owner really wants to live. Given how valuable they are, few owners who don't want to live here would rather rent out their condos rather than simply sell them. Take my East Village condo building, for instance: when it went condo in 1983, only one owner lived here. Today, all the units bar one are owner-occupied. I haven't done my homework on this, but I'll happily accept your wager: I'll bet the standard bottle of vintage champagne that more than half the condos in Manhattan are owner-occupied. Deal? Posted by: Felix on December 6, 2005 02:43 AM #27 If you go double or nothing on the proposition that the amount of existing residential floor space in Manhattan divided by the number of residents of Manhattan is equal to or greater than 600 sq. ft., then it's a bet. How are we going to research this? FWIW, I am descended from a man who is reputed to be the first person to negotiate a real estate deal in New York: Wessel Wesselse (ten Broek). He may have been the man to offer 60 guilders (often misreported as $24) as the purchase price of Manhattan from the Canarsies. (Technically the Canarsies didn't own Manhattan Island - it's not for nothing that "Canarsie" is in Brooklyn. Also technically the Dutch West India Company didn't care which tribe owned it. It just needed some bunch of natives to smile and sign off on the deal to keep the English away.) This of course conveys no special knowledge upon me, but it certainly adds a humorous subtext to our disagreement. Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 04:14 AM #28 I'm not sure about the terms of the wager: we seem to be betting on two different things at the same time. But spell it out, and I'll be amenable. I do want to ensure, of course, that hallways and elevator shafts and the like do not count as residential floor space. And please also ensure that if one of the propositions can be determined while the other one can't, then the other wager still stands. Posted by: Felix on December 6, 2005 05:55 AM #29 I'm not sure how we could specify the terms to exclude elevators if they are included in filings. However, it occurs to me that Manhattan Borough probably requires a statement of total dwelling space for its Certificate of Occupancy, so that would work for me. And no, I think double or nothing sounds good to me, especially since we will be attempting to falsify two of my estimations, rather than either of yours. Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 06:20 AM #30 You've lost me, I'm afraid. When you say "double or nothing", are you proposing a 2BVC bet on the residential floor space, and no bet at all on the proportion of condos which are rented out? Or what? It makes no sense to me: "double or nothing" normally happens after A has lost a bet and B has won it. Then going double or nothing means that either B wins double the original amount, or he wins nothing. You essentially run the bet over again. Are you maybe trying to propose something whereby if I lose I lose 2BVCs, and if I win I win nothing? Posted by: Felix on December 6, 2005 07:44 AM #31 Are you trying to squirm out of it? Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 06:03 PM #32 Sterling, will you propose your bet already? I've already said that I'm likely to accept. Just tell me the terms! Posted by: Felix on December 6, 2005 06:12 PM #33 I did! Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 06:25 PM #34 OK, have a few moments now, I had to get someplace before 2pm and the roads are crap with snow and slush. Um, OK. My terms for the bet is those two things specified, avg. sq. footage = 600 and = 50% of condos. Either side has to get both right to collect. gotta run Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 06:51 PM #35 So if one of us gets both right, he wins 1BVC or 2BVCs? And if one of the two turns out to be unverifiable, then it's a wash? Posted by: Felix on December 6, 2005 07:22 PM #36 Honestly, Felix, I doubt either number is verifiable. Like I wrote above, the city appears to track residential rental inventory by units, rather than by square footage. Also, most owners of condominium units who rent them out do so through agents - even the tenant may be only vaguely aware of the legal status of the unit. In NJ I don't think an individual condo owner even needs to report the unit as a rental property if it's in a building that's already inspected under multi-family housing regulations (or if it's a standalone unit or duplex). The rent revenue has to be reported as taxable income, naturallly, but not to any entity with housing oversight. So make it for one bottle and yes both figures have to be verifiable. That said, if either of us can show a grouping of not-completely-conclusive figures from multiple sources that seem reasonable and fall long or short of my guesses by ten percent or more, then I think we should accept them. (Of course, I have arguably already met this condition with my square footage prediction, and Geoff's calculations don't contradict it under the 10% rule I suggest.) Posted by: Sterling on December 6, 2005 10:05 PM #37 as i mentioned earlier, you can get the sf and unit count for every residential tax lot in the city from the cities web site... google 'bytes of the big apple' and look at the 'pluto' product. the license fee is $250 or you can get the info from propertyshark.com. there are 99000+ listings for manhattan. at 100 listings per page, thats a lot of cutting and pasting into excel. both of these will give you tax lot sizes (whole buildings/unit count or condo unit), which will be inclusive of common area. 10-15% is considered a fairly standard deduction for circulation. mechanical space is not included in the floor area count. happy dueling Posted by: geoff on December 6, 2005 10:29 PM Post a comment Name: Email Address: URL: Remember personal info? Yes No Anti-spam question: Share four cupcakes equally among four people. How many does each person get (in digits)? Comments: XML Atom RSS 2.0 RSS 1.0 Sources Eurof Felix Jame Michelle Mike Sage7 Stefan Sterling &c. Disclaimer Archive 12/05 11/05 10/05 09/05 08/05 07/05 06/05 05/05 04/05 03/05 02/05 01/05 12/04 11/04 10/04 09/04 08/04 07/04 06/04 05/04 04/04 03/04 02/04 01/04 12/03 11/03 10/03 09/03 Old site Recent posts 08/12: Not man enough (1) 08/12: Fare's fair (0) 07/12: Briddishisms (5) 06/12: The Trial of Saddam (5) 05/12: Leg deficiencies (4) 01/12: New York real-estate prices explained (37) 30/11: Bad vibe (22) 30/11: Thick-headed bouncers (0) 29/11: Argentina's sinister move (2) 28/11: Bedbugs and the city (8) 27/11: I've got a fast card (1) 22/11: Pedestrianize Broadway! (5) 19/11: Century 21 the next casualty at Ground Zero? (23) 19/11: Johnny Depp - sunshine traitor (4) 18/11: Gawker F***** by Yahoo! (7) Comments 06/12: geoff: as i mentioned earlier, you can get the sf and unit count for every residential tax lot in the ci 06/12: Sterling: Honestly, Felix, I doubt either number is verifiable. Like I wrote above, the city appears to tr 06/12: Felix: So if one of us gets both right, he wins 1BVC or 2BVCs? And if one of the two turns out to be unv 06/12: Sterling: OK, have a few moments now, I had to get someplace before 2pm and the roads are crap with snow an 06/12: Sterling: I did! 06/12: Felix: Sterling, will you propose your bet already? I've already said that I'm likely to accept. Just te 06/12: Sterling: Are you trying to squirm out of it? 06/12: Felix: You've lost me, I'm afraid. When you say "double or nothing", are you proposing a 2BVC bet on the 06/12: Sterling: I'm not sure how we could specify the terms to exclude elevators if they are included in filings. 06/12: Felix: I'm not sure about the terms of the wager: we seem to be betting on two different things at the s 06/12: Sterling: If you go double or nothing on the proposition that the amount of existing residential floor spac 06/12: Felix: Sterling, I'm afraid the factors leading to high apartment prices are much more mundane than your 06/12: Sterling: "Manhattan is the one real-estate market in the US where there are, to all intents and purposes, 05/12: Felix: Sterling, Manhattan is the one real-estate market in the US where there are, to all intents and p 05/12: sac: This thread is hilarious and sad, although a good example of how the same statistics can be appli 05/12: Sterling: Felix, just because apartments are currently going for $1.21 million a pop doesn't mean that ever 05/12: 99: There's the shark, and then there's the A train. Sterling's Manhattan clearly stops at 96th stree 05/12: Felix: Renter-occupied apartments are much smaller than owner-occupied apartments. And as the < 05/12: Sterling: Geoff - The only reason I was pompously snug is because Felix had reacted to to my estimates with 05/12: geoff: if anyone is real curious why not pony up the $250 to get a list of every tax lot in the city?<br 04/12: Sterling: The multiplier of 4 was back-of-envelope guess. The 280,000,000 number came from <a href 04/12: Felix: Where does your 280m sq ft number come from? Your first two calculations are based on it, so I'd 04/12: 99: Sterling: do your calculations include infrastructure or is the 280MM number a percentage of raw 04/12: Sterling: I've tried to find the statistic, but to no avail. It seems that while office space inventor is 04/12: Sterling: My claim is that the amount of residential-zoned floor space in Manhattan probably works out to b 04/12: Felix: Sterling jumped the shark so long ago it's probably not surprising, but for those of you keeping 04/12: Sterling: OK, 22 square miles equals about 613,324,800 square feet. That would leave each of Manhattan's 1 03/12: Felix: OK, Sterling, let's do it your way. Assume that each of the 1.5 million residents of Manhattan ha 03/12: Sterling: I don't think I'm confused. My points are: a) there is actually quite a bit more than 22 02/12: Andrew: Susan and Sterling, you are embarassingly confused. What percentage of real estate in Manhattan i Trackbacks

Real Estate Loan

Find Mortgage Calculators, Today's Rates on Mortgages, Refinance Loans and Home Equity Loans on Yahoo! Real Estate This tool will only function with browsers which support JavaScript version 1.1 or later. Find Mortgage Calculators, Today's Rates on Mortgages, Refinance Loans and Home Equity Loans Choose Location Home Homes For Sale Apartments for Rent Home Loans Moving & Insurance Tools My Real Estate Real Estate > Home Loans > Calculators > Mortgage Payment Calculator Tools & Resources • Mortgage Payment Calculator • Affordability Calculator • Amortization Calculator • Rent vs. Own Calculator • Refinance Calculator • First-Time Buyer's Guide to Mortgages Next Steps: • Search Local Rates • Online Rate Quotes • Graph Interest Rates • Refinance Loans & Rates • Home Equity Loans & Rates Mortgage Payment Calculator Provided by Bankrate.com This mortgage calculator shows monthly mortgage payments for different home loan amounts, interest rates and amortzation terms. You can view the amortization schedule by selecting to show the amortization table below. Loan Amount: $ Interest Rate: % Term (years): years Show Amortization Table?: Yes No See more calculators Visit our partners' sites Sponsored Links Home Refinancing ChoiceOne Mortgage offers a variety of home refinancing options. Fill out the quick app for a rate quote. www.choiceonemortgage.net Your Guide to Refinancing - Homestore Find information, articles and quotes for home refinance loans in your area. We have the loan that's right for you. Complete our easy form and get free, competitive quotes. homestore.com Home Mortgage Refinance Refinance your home mortgage to lower your payment now. Complete four easy steps and get matched to four qualified brokers. www.mortgages.root.net Capital One Home Refinance Lower your payments an avg. $400 a month. A personal home loan consultant will work with you to find a loan that fits your needs. Apply online and receive a call back within 30 minutes. www.capitalone.com (Become a Sponsor) Homes For Sale - Apartments For Rent - Current Mortgage Rates - Real Estate Agents - Local - Yellow Pages

Home Mortgage

NY LI CT Jumbo Mortgages-first in home mortgages refinancing homeequity loans Program Rate APR 30yr Fixed 6.000 6.028 15yr Fixed 5.625 5.665 30yr Jumbo 6.250 6.262 15yr Jumbo 5.875 5.895 Adjustable 5/1 ARM 5.625 6.259 More Rates AMERICANA MORTGAGE GROUP SAVES YOU TIME AND MONEY We're first in jumbomortgages , home equity loans and refinancing of residential real estate inNew York, Long Island, Nassau, Suffolk, Queens and Connecticut. Americana Mortgage Group is also the fastest growing mortgage brokerage in the NY tri-statearea-- with over 90% of our loans coming from returning satisfied clients andtheir referrals . We pride ourselves on proven customer service and money savingtechniques. Our reputation is your guarantee. Improve your chances of getting the home loan andmortgage interest rates you want. Apply online right now . Or contact us today at 1-888-262-6685. Here's what to expect: Best Mortgage Rates andPrograms for Loans Large or Small, Long or Short-Term. Extended Rate Locks. Free Rate Float Downs. No Prepayment Penalties. We offer a variety of residential loans -- conventional and jumbo mortgages -- and creative financing strategies--such as no incomecheck loans, below market rate programs , nomortgage insurance options, biweekly programs , 100%financing for no money down real estate purchases, no point mortgages,bridge loans, interest only mortgages. Check out today's mortgageinterest rates and use our mortgage calculator tosee what you can afford. Americana Mortgage Group also arranges financingfor: a new home purchase, co-op or condo loans first-time home buyers jumbo mortgages and refinancing for luxury homes and home equity loan dreams self-employed no income check loans a second home or investment property land and construction loans debt consolidation, and those with bad credit home equity loans for home improvements or financing a college education Personal MortgageShoppers Do All the Research for You Our mortgage loanofficers are top notch. They're skilled in shopping the mortgage rates andterms of over 100 national banks and local lenders, to find the right loanprogram and mortgage lender fit for every client. With their expertise at work,you'll get qualified faster for an earlier loan approval. Get a Mortgage Loan--Quicklyand Simply. Office Visits Optional! Our processing is so streamlined that alltransactions can be done by mail , phone, fax, and email. No matter the method,your home loan will get the same priority and attention we give to clients whoprefer to do business in-person--at either of our NewYork, LI mortgage offices in Manhasset and Southampton . Yourconfidentiality is always ensured. Apply for a Home Loan RightNow Take a few minutes to complete our secure Express Online Mortgage Application . Try our mortgage payment calculator too! Email us , or apply over the phone at 516-627-0200 x10 to talk to an expert for a free no-riskconsultation and to get today's mortgage interestrates .

foreclosure property foreclosure real

Foreclosure Listings Information at Business.com Advertiser Center · Help Web News People Jobs Search the Business Internet ® Foreclosure Listings Databases and listings of residential, government and bank-owned foreclosures. Home > Real Estate & Construction > Property Listings > Foreclosure Sub-Categories Bank Owned Reference US States -- -- Featured Listings Foreclosures.com: Real Estate Foreclosures Provides buyers of foreclosures with premium training on foreclosures, current listings of foreclosures, and reference information. www.foreclosures.com RealtyStore: Foreclosure Listings Save 20 - 50% on Foreclosure and HUD real estate. Ideal for investors, bargain hunters and first timers. Free trial membership (Credit Card required). www.realtystore.com ForeclosuresMass: The Investors Choice for MA Foreclosures ForeclosuresMass lists all foreclosed properties in the state of Massachusetts weeks before they're printed in the paper or recorded at the registry. MA Foreclosures | Search By County | MA Stats www.foreclosuresmass.com Sponsored Links Foreclosure Listings Save big on local foreclosed homes. Savings 20-50% below market rates. www.RealtyTrac.com I'm Paying Cash For Homes Any Price, Condition, Or Location Sell Your Home Quickly & Easily www.webuyhomesaz.com Foreclosure Listings Buy Foreclosures from 50% off Search 600,000 listings for only $1 www.Bargain.com/Foreclosures More Featured Listings RealtyTrac: Foreclosed Property Listings Provides foreclosure search engine for all 50 states with daily data updates, tax roll information, and photographs. Free 7-day trial. www.realtytrac.com eBay: Foreclosure Listings Online marketplace for buying and selling foreclosure listings. www.ebay.com Sponsored Links We Help Stop Foreclosure Cash For Any Home in All Conditions No Fees Or Commissions. Just Cash! www.AllHomesAZ.com We Buy Homes Fast We will buy your house directly from you. No Fees AllHousesAZ.com Free Foreclosure Service No Money Down Homes Search Foreclosure Listings Free iForeclosures.com Fresh Bankruptcy Lists Custom lists. Phone #, address, etc Accurate. Daily Updates. High ROI. www.ClickData.com Pre- foreclosure Leads Freshest lists available Az, Ca, Fl, Mi, Nm, Wa www.defaultresearch.com Free Foreclosure Search Save up to 50% on your next home purchase. Start your free trial now www.ForeclosureTimes.com Popular Searches commercial foreclosure corporate foreclosure distressed properties distressed property distressed real estate foeclosure home foeclosure house forclos home forclos house « more more popular searches [x] forclose home forclose house forcloser home forcloser house forclosesure home forclosesure house forcloseur home forcloseur house forcloseure home forcloseure house forclosing home forclosing house forclosue home forclosue house forclosure forclosure home forclosure homes forclosure house forclosure loans Forclosure property listing Forclosure property listings forcloures home forcloures house forclouser home forclouser house forclousure home forclousure house forclusure home forclusure house forcolsure home forcolsure house foreclos home foreclos house foreclose home foreclose house foreclosed foreclosed home foreclosed home for sale foreclosed homes foreclosed houses foreclosed properties foreclosed property forecloser home forecloser house foreclosesure home foreclosesure house forecloseur home forecloseur house forecloseure home forecloseure house foreclosing home foreclosing house foreclosue home foreclosue house foreclosure assistance foreclosure financing foreclosure home foreclosure homes foreclosure house foreclosure list foreclosure listing foreclosure listings foreclosure loans foreclosure opportunities foreclosure opportunity foreclosure properties foreclosure property foreclosure real estate foreclosure sale foreclosure search foreclosures forecloures home forecloures house foreclouser home foreclousure home foreclousure house foreclusure home foreclusure house forecolsure home fourclos home fourclos house fourclose home fourclose house fourcloser home fourcloser house fourclosesure home fourclosesure house fourcloseur home fourcloseur house fourcloseure home fourcloseure house fourclosing home fourclosing house fourclosue home fourclosue house fourclosure home fourclosure house fourcloures home fourcloures house fourclousure home fourclousure house fourclusure home fourclusure house fourcolsure home fourcolsure house government foreclosure home foreclosure home foreclosures homes foreclosed house foreclosure property foreclosures real estate foreclosure real estate foreclosures real estate owned REO reo properties reo property repo home Listings Absolute Foreclosures: National Foreclosure Listings National bank and government foreclosure listings updated daily and real estate auctions. Free seven day trial. Directory | FREE Trial | Register | Search www.absoluteforeclosures.com All Foreclosure Information Foreclosure information & databases. www.all-foreclosure.com American Foreclosures Offers a nationwide database of foreclosure properties, including government, VA, and bank foreclosures. Subscription required. www.americanforeclosures.com Appraisal Network-Forclosures Forclosure listings by state. www.appraisal-network.com Bank Foreclosure Listings Provides foreclosure search engine for all 50 states with a 7-day trial membership. www.foreclosure-bank-listings.com Bates Foreclosure Report Subscription based service providing lists of real estate foreclosures. www.brucebates.com Buyers' Edge Limited- Foreclosure Report Tracks all properities in the process of foreclosure, from pre-foreclosure to foreclosure auction. www.foreclosurereport.com California Homes Online Repossessed homes & single family home listings in the State of California. www.californiahomesonline.com Community Commerce Bank Listings of real estate owned properties. www.communitycommercebank.com County Records Research Stewart title county record search. www.stewarttitle.com eBay: Foreclosure Listings Online marketplace for buying and selling foreclosure listings. www.ebay.com Fannie Mae-Owned Properties Fannie Mae-Owned Properties - Single family homes available for sale. fanniemae.com Fast Cash in Foreclosure: Real Estate Foreclosures Investing Real estate training course provides insider information for buying bank foreclosures and distressed properties from home. Discussion Forum | Bank Foreclosures www.fastcashinrealestateforeclosures.com Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation FDIC property retrieval system. www2.fdic.gov Federal Foreclosure Information Services Nationwide foreclosure listings of bank and government real estate. www.foreclosureinfo.net Federal Real Estate Services Foreclosures listed nationwide. www.federal-services.com Foreclosure Central Nationwide directory of foreclosure listings. www.foreclosurecentral.com Foreclosure Connections.com Contains tax lien, foreclosure, and pre-foreclosure listings in the United States. Listings updated daily. www.foreclosureconnections.com Foreclosure Databank.com Provides an online resource of foreclosure listings, including VA, FHA, HUD, and REO properties listed in all 50 states. Database updated daily. About Us | Foreclosures | Site Map | News www.foreclosuredatabank.com Foreclosure Deals Corp. Provides a database of listings, resources, and tools necessary to find foreclosure homes nationwide. Membership required. About Us | Foreclosures | SiteMap www.foreclosuredeals.com Foreclosure Free Search Database of foreclosure listings nationwide. www.foreclosurefreesearch.com Foreclosure Leads Residential and commercial foreclosure listings. www.foreclosureleads.com Foreclosure Listings Bank & Government foreclosures. www.foreclosurelistings.com Foreclosure Reporting Service Publishes lists of new foreclosure cases filed in the counties of Broward, and Palm Beach, Florida. www.foreclosure-report.com Foreclosure Trac Review all of our lis pendens and auction sale data online through our database covering every one of the 8 New York metropolitan counties. www.foreclosuretrac.com Foreclosure-Repo-Auction.com Provides up-to-date foreclosure listings in all 50 states. Registration required. About Us | SiteMap | Contact Us www.foreclosure-repo-auction.com ForeclosureFreeSearch.com foreclosurefreesearch.com ForeclosureListingsNationWide.com, Inc. Provides an online database that has hundreds of thousands of foreclosure listings, including REO (bank owned), HUD, tax lien foreclosures, and more. 7 day trial membership to join. About Us | News | Foreclosures | SiteMap www.foreclosurelistingsnationwide.com ForeclosureNet.net: Foreclosure Property Listings Offers bank foreclosure and government foreclosured property listings across the US. Includes homes, rental properties, retail, and commercial. Free Trial | Search Listings | Foreclosure Info. | Testimonials www.foreclosurenet.net Foreclosures USA Nationwide bank & government foreclosure listings. www.foreclosuresusa.net Foreclosures.com Foreclosure lists-information. www.foreclosures.com Foreclosures.com: Real Estate Foreclosures Provides buyers of foreclosures with premium training on foreclosures, current listings of foreclosures, and reference information. www.foreclosures.com ForeClosureSeekers LLC Provider of online foreclosure property search services. Services are provided to real estate professionals and consumers. This company was capitalized by corporate investment. www.foreclosureseekers.com ForeclosuresMass: The Investors Choice for MA Foreclosures ForeclosuresMass lists all foreclosed properties in the state of Massachusetts weeks before they're printed in the paper or recorded at the registry. MA Foreclosures | Search By County | MA Stats www.foreclosuresmass.com ForeclosuresNet www.bankhomes.net ForeclosureWarehouse.com Provides property listings for more than 400.000 foreclosed homes in all 50 states. Updated daily. About Us | SiteMap | News | Glossary www.foreclosurewarehouse.com Foreclosureworld Foreclosure multiple listing service. www.foreclosureworld.net GovBargains Subscription based foreclosure searches. www.govbargains.com Green Point Financial Official website of Green Point Financial. www.greenpoint.com IRS Siezed Property Listings of Internal Revenue Service siezed property. www.treas.gov Metwest Mortgage Foreclosure properties for sale. www.metmtg.com MostlyForeclosures Provides database of nationwide foreclosure listings. Trial membership. Listings updated daily. www.mostlyforeclosures.com RealtyStore: Foreclosure Listings Save 20 - 50% on Foreclosure and HUD real estate. Ideal for investors, bargain hunters and first timers. Free trial membership (Credit Card required). www.realtystore.com RealtyTrac: Foreclosed Property Listings Provides foreclosure search engine for all 50 states with daily data updates, tax roll information, and photographs. Free 7-day trial. www.realtytrac.com Small Business Administration Property listings for sale. www.sba.gov US Foreclosure Network Educational & informational resource on legislative and regulatory developments, educational forums, and foreclosure and bankruptcy law. www.usfn.org Sponsored Links Foreclosure Listings Save big on local foreclosed homes. Savings 20-50% below market rates. www.RealtyTrac.com I'm Paying Cash For Homes Any Price, Condition, Or Location Sell Your Home Quickly & Easily www.webuyhomesaz.com Foreclosure Listings Buy Foreclosures from 50% off Search 600,000 listings for only $1 www.Bargain.com/Foreclosures Search the Business Internet ® Advertiser Center | Account Login | About Us | Careers at Business.com | Featured Listings Privacy | Terms Of Use | 2000-2005 Business.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Sell House

Man wins suit to sell house occupied by sect Man wins suit to sell house occupied by sect He's been trying to sell the $1.8m house since he left sect and moved out but sect members occupying it claimed they had right to live there The Straits Times/August 17, 2004 By Elena Chong A former Singapore Airlines pilot yesterday won a court order to sell a $1.8 million house in Sembawang, in which several members of religious sect House of Israel have been staying. Mr Steven Joshua, 56, who co-owns the 792.8 sq m place with four others, had sued former wife Deborah Steven Joshua, 55; his sister, Madam Rachel Jacob, 50; and three other couples staying there. He has been trying to sell the place since he left the group in 2001 and moved out. However, the sect members claimed there was a property covenant that entitled them to live there. They now have up to mid-November to move out of the Sembawang Place bungalow. Mr Joshua had also sued another sister, Mrs Rebekah Isaac, 47, and her husband, Mr Isaac Benjamin, 49, who left the group in 1993. They did not contest the suit as they too wanted to sell the property. They will be given a 20 per cent share of the proceeds of the sale. Mr Joshua, his ex-wife, his two sisters and Mr Benjamin bought the house for $700,000 in 1986 and registered it in their names. At the time, they belonged to the religious group, which hit the headlines nine years ago when three of its members lost a libel suit against The Straits Times for describing it as a 'sect'. Yesterday, Justice Tan Lee Meng threw out the defendants' counterclaim, saying they had not proven their case. The net proceeds of the sale of the Sembawang home have to be distributed among the co-owners, said the judge, with Mr Benjamin and his wife getting 20 per cent and the other three - Mr Joshua, his ex-wife and Madam Jacob - sharing the remainder according to the proportion they paid for the property. Mr Joshua, who also won on costs, was represented by Mr James Ponniah. Mr Daniel John acted for all the defendants except Mr Benjamin and his wife. To see more documents/articles regarding this group/organization/subject click here . Home Database Cult News Search Getting Help Forum Mind Control Legal Contact Us About Us What's New Headlines Links Books Help RRI FAQ